The 2024 NFL preseason, while short-lived, provides a crucial glimpse into the potential impact of the league's newest additions. This year's crop of first-round rookies hit the field with varying degrees of success, and as we sift through the tape, some performances stand out more than others.
Quarterback Performances
Caleb Williams had a mixed bag of results. Completing 50% of his throws while averaging 8.5 yards per attempt, Williams played 42 snaps over the preseason. His precision and decision-making will need to tighten as the regular season approaches.
Jayden Daniels, in contrast, displayed commendable efficiency. Completing 12 of his 15 attempts for 123 yards, Daniels maintained his composure, finishing with neither touchdowns nor interceptions. His ball security and accuracy will likely earn him trust from the coaching staff.
Drake Maye's preseason was a tale of two stories. In the first two preseason games, he threw for 66 yards on 8 of 14 passing. However, he shifted gears in the finale against the Commanders, completing 13 of 20 passes for 126 yards and a touchdown. These glimpses of brilliance show potential for significant growth.
Michael Penix Jr. and Bo Nix both executed solid outings, with Penix completing 9 of 16 for 104 yards and Nix mirroring this stat line in his lone preseason appearance. Their limited but effective showings indicate promise under center.
Standout Skill Positions
Wide receivers showed a spectrum of readiness. Malik Nabers made his mark with four catches for 54 yards in his second preseason game, hinting at his ability to contribute immediately. Rome Odunze had a quieter showing, recording just one catch, albeit a notable one for 45 yards.
Brian Thomas Jr. provided some excitement with three catches tallying 93 yards across the preseason, showcasing his deep-threat potential. Conversely, Xavier Worthy scored a touchdown but also fumbled, an early indication of areas needing discipline and focus.
O-Line and Defense Evaluations
On the offensive line, performances varied. Joe Alt showed significant improvement in his second preseason game, especially in pass protection, a critical trait for the longevity of any quarterback. Olu Fashanu faced a learning curve as he allowed pressure on his first professional pass-pro set but demonstrated effectiveness in run blocking.
Defensive pass-rushers, a crucial component of any team, had several notable appearances. Laiatu Latu impressed with a sack in just 13 pass-rushing snaps during Indianapolis's third game. Byron Murphy and Dallas Turner each generated two pressures on 20 pass-rushing snaps, with Turner showcasing valuable consistency in disrupting the pocket.
On the flip side, Chop Robinson struggled to make an impact with no pressures recorded across two games, emphasizing the volatility of rookie adaptation periods.
Defensive Coverage and Special Teams Highlights
Quinyon Mitchell's preseason tranquility in the secondary, allowing only two catches for eight yards, speaks volumes about his coverage skills. Similarly, Nate Wiggins showcased standout defensive efforts with three pass breakups in one drive during the preseason and no receptions allowed on two targets in the final game.
Linemen on Both Sides
J.C. Latham's performance exemplified balance and power in the run game, paired with suddenness in pass protection, while Graham Barton also displayed effective run blocking, suggesting these young linemen could anchor their respective units effectively.
In special teams, Tyler Guyton showed positive signs across two preseason matchups, adding depth to his role within the squad.
As we transition from preseason evaluations to the rigor of regular-season play, these grades provide a glimpse into the potential these first-round picks hold. Teams will be looking to these rookies to translate their limited showings into consistent, impactful performances as the 2024 NFL season kicks off in earnest.
